Search
Close this search box.
National Alliance Statement on 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Ruling on Charter Schools

National Alliance Statement on 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Ruling on Charter Schools

August 13, 2021

On August 9, 2021, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals included in a ruling that charter schools should not be considered “state actors,” and are therefore not subject to the Equal Protection Clause. Nina Rees, President and CEO of the National Alliance of Public Charter Schools, issued the following statement.

“The National Alliance strongly disagrees with the ruling in Peltier v. Charter Day School that this school is a private actor and therefore does not need to uphold the Equal Protection rights of its students.

“All charter schools are public schools. This is clearly, and unequivocally, articulated in every state charter statute across the country and in federal statute. Moreover, every state charter statute recognizes charter schools as part of the state’s public education ecosystem.  As such, we firmly believe charter schools cannot discriminate against any student on the basis of sex, gender, race, disability, or religious preference. We insist every charter school student must be given the same federal and state civil rights and constitutional protections as their district school peers.

“This case challenged the Equal Protection rights of students in charter schools in North Carolina. As the dissent notes, this ruling is not only based on antiquated thinking, but is illogical when one considers that the NC legislature created charter schools as public schools and the federal government declares them to be as public as any district-run school.

“Fortunately for the students, the court rightly recognized that the civil rights of students are still protected because charter schools are the recipients of federal funds. Nonetheless, we do not understand how the court arrived at its conclusion that Charter Day School was a private actor, and we will support plaintiffs’ position in any appeal.”

October 19, 2021 Update: At the request of plaintiffs, with amicus support from the National Alliance, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted additional (known as “en banc”) review of the earlier 4th Circuit ruling in Peltier v. Charter Day School. We are hopeful that upon en banc review, the court will affirm that all charter schools are public schools.

 

help us advocate for more charter schools & increased funding!
find a charter school near you on our interactive map!

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

trophy icon

Memorial Gifts

Contact Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994.

trophy icon

Commemorative Gifts

Contact Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994.

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

Notice

You are now leaving the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools Website

STAY INFORMED

Get the latest charter school updates straight to your inbox.

shapes icon

Wire Transfers

For questions regarding wire transfers, please email of call Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994.

shapes icon

Gifts of Stock

For questions regarding stock, please email of call Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994.

shapes icon

Matching Gifts

If you or your spouse work for a company that provides matching gifts, you can make an even bigger impact! To have your gift matched, you must submit your company’s completed matching gift form.

Please send all completed matching gift forms to:

National Alliance for Public Charter Schools
800 Connecticut Ave. N.W. Suite 300
Washington, DC 20006.

If this donation will be potentially matched, please provide the company name.

Advocates Council

Contact Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994.

calendar icon

Legacy Society

Contact Celia Hagerman at [email protected] or 202-600-8994 to learn more about the Legacy Society or for any other inquiries regarding planned giving.